What Is Payroll Fraud + How To Detect & Prevent It

There are several different types of payroll fraud, each with its own set of consequences. It’s essential to understand each type to take steps to prevent it from happening at your company.

The individuals had bona fide roles with the municipality but did very little work—clocking in, drawing their salaries, but not actually performing any services. A hidden camera captured one employee placing a cardboard box over their head to avoid detection while clocking in many colleagues. These evaluations should include cyber and fraud risk assessments, and audits of financial documents and employee schedules. The first will help you to identify any potential vulnerabilities that need to be addressed.

Outsourcing Payroll Services

If businesses aren’t diligent, the toll of this deception and theft can be considerable. Have someone in internal audit or an external CPA or CFE randomly select employees, comparing the master pay rates for each person to the personnel files. Let the payroll and human resources employees know that this test will be performed once a year. The knowledge of the test will be a deterrent to fraudulent increases in the master pay rate file.

• The IRS also released guidance on the program’s retroactive termination.
• Or, cost less than the employee reported, allowing them to pocket the difference.
• If you’re new to payroll accounting, some of them may be unfamiliar to you, so let’s take a few minutes and brush up on our fundamental knowledge of payroll fraud and the way it is most commonly committed.
• However, any company can prevent this type of fraud by implementing a system where employees must submit receipts for all expenses.
• Take the time to regularly review all financial statements for any unusual activity.
• Here are 5 steps you can take to identify and prevent payroll fraud in the workplace.

Well-hidden fraud is not obvious to most business owners, and it is not always intentional. Sadly, by the time most payroll fraud is discovered, lots of time has passed. The resulting losses could add up to hundreds of thousands of dollars, if not more. Payroll fraud can occur in any business, in any industry–from the small corner store to big, multi-national corporations.

Report: Wage Theft, Payroll Fraud Hurting Wi Construction Workers

For example, ghost employees, timesheet fraud, and false expense reimbursement. A Ghost employee is a person who is on the payroll but does not work for the company.

Fraud is more common in larger firms than in smaller ones, and it is more often when personnel is dispersed over multiple physical locations, but the payroll function is managed from a single site. Did you know that most businesses lose out on a significant amount of money each year by neglecting to take advantage of tax deductions? Organizations should outline expense policies clearly by making it mandatory for employees to produce receipts whenever they are making an expense claim.

Generating False Time Sheets

It’s always good to review payroll reports after payroll processing to ensure that employees are receiving their correct pay. It is also important to cross-check employees’ addresses and bank account numbers to see if multiple payments have been made to the same bank account which is a way of committing Payroll Fraud. Each of these employee fraud schemes are a risk to companies who conduct their payroll in-house, but improving internal controls, processes and policy can significantly reduce your risk of damages.

While it may not be possible or feasible to review the payroll every single pay period, there should be at least several in-depth reviews throughout the year. Auditing your own payroll could also provide the benefit of a more long-term view, which could result in you noticing a troubling trend here and there. Having internal checks and balances as well as an outside source to double check everything from data entry to tax payments is also a good idea.

Benefits Of Outsourcing Payroll

You might also wish to include a description of what constitutes payroll fraud and the consequences of being found guilty of it. This type of fraud is where an employee increases their rate of pay, pays themselves overtime, or intentionally gives himself or herself a bonus or commission not actually earned. Nearly always, someone working within the payroll function is committing this type of fraud. As a loan payment heading was used, there will be no reflection in year-to-date balances on the pay advice, so the genuine employee will have no reason to notice what the fraudster has done. Earlier this year, nearly half a million dollars was diverted from the payroll of employees who work in Tallahassee, Florida. In this case, the cybercriminals who performed the attack actually hacked into the city’s direct deposit payroll system. With both W-2 and payroll diversion fraud, the employees — and their employers — are often on the losing end of these situations.

• Not at the 2016 IDEA User Conference but would like to know more training on how to use IDEA Data Analysis software for detecting fraud?
• Editorial content from The Ascent is separate from The Motley Fool editorial content and is created by a different analyst team.
• Rather than having additional funds at the ready to allocate towards…
• Payroll fraud can be detrimental for all businesses in all industries, but particularly small businesses.
• Review a list of all active employees against your payroll register.
• No assurance is given that the information is comprehensive in its coverage or that it is suitable in dealing with a customer’s particular situation.

Below are a few examples of how to detect and prevent payroll fraud. In payroll ghosting, the payment is often made using false documents or someone else’s identity and social security number. This type of fraud is common in industries where employees are paid cash, such as the restaurant industry. However, it can also happen in other industries where employees are paid through payroll services.

Payroll Blog

Keep a close eye on your business’s cash outflow, or cash leaving the company, when employees with financial responsibilities are on vacation. You might have a fraudster in your ranks if there’s an unexpectedly sharp decrease in outgoing cash. It’s standard in many industries to reimburse employees for expenses they incurred on behalf of the business. It’s not standard to grant reimbursements without verifiable proof of payment, however. Similar to unapproved bonuses, unsanctioned raises happen when someone with access to payroll makes changes to employee hourly rates or salary.

• Such fraud might utilise the valid payroll records for deceased or ex-employees.
• Surprise audits contribute to the largest reductions in fraud loss and duration and only32% of fraud cases in the U.S. use them as an anti-fraud control.
• For help preventing paycheck diversion, check out our guides on setting up direct deposit and the best pay card providers.
• Because the amounts are so great, payroll fraud warrants special attention.
• As criminals become more creative, it’s up to all of us to become more vigilant.
• When done alone, the payroll department employee transfers the extra pay to another account before issuing the employee’s paycheck for the correct amount.

Have management check the payroll listing from time to time looking for suspicious names and addresses, and randomly meet employees on the payroll register. For businesses with manageable numbers of employees, have a non-payroll person randomly walk around with a payroll list and meet every employee on the list. The risk of a ghost being added increases when there is a high turnover of staff. It increases again when the business has part-time or casual employees and the payroll staff see a variety of names come and go from the wages list. This reduces the chance that a ghost will be recognized amongst the numerous changing names. The fraud is usually done in businesses with large numbers of employees, particularly when employees are spread over a number of physical locations and where the payroll function is controlled centrally.

However, any company can prevent this type of fraud by implementing a system where employees must submit receipts for all expenses. Unfortunately, this type of fraud is often difficult to detect, as it requires a close inspection of the timesheets. However, suppose your company relies on an in-out badging system. In that case, you can easily detect this type of fraud once all the timesheets are reviewed and compared against the employee’s actual entry and departure time. Unless there is a protocol in place for managers to track and report time theft, it will likely go unreported. And since 43% of hourly workers admit to exaggerating the amount of time they work at least once, tracking these offenses should be top of mind for employers.

The first tactic is used to get the victim to provide sensitive personal and/or financial information. https://www.bookstime.com/ Institute a policy with your employees that requires a receipt for reimbursement, with no exceptions.

In Michigan, a victim is an individual who suffers direct or threatened physical, financial, or emotional harm as a result of the commission of a crime. The Charitable Trust Section functions for Michigan citizens as a repository of financial and other information about charities they may want to support. At any one time there are more than 8,000 charities registered with the Attorney General’s Charitable Trust Section.

You could also have executives approve all overtime and commission checks. This may prevent employees from adding a few extra hours or sales here and there, thinking it won’t be detected. One of the easiest ways to ensure a strong and reliable payroll process is by using a payroll software that allows you to manage your employees, payments, and taxes all in one place. For help deciding which one is best for you, check out our guide to the top payroll software for small businesses. In-house international payroll systems that are harder to police, like those in large organizations with high employee turnover or a dispersed workforce, are an easy target for theft. But, small businesses are also at risk, especially if their payroll system is managed or overseen by one person.

Do An Internal Audit Of Payroll Taxes

Heather is a staff writer and payroll specialist with several years of experience working directly with small business owners. Her expertise allows her to deliver the best answers to your questions about payroll. Payroll processes can become impaired for various reasons—and these reasons are often most evident in times of global expansion. Find out how a payroll transformation can benefit your business. At the very least, your payroll processing system should be reconciled quarterly with someone other than the person who runs your payroll. Don’t rush to sign up with the first payroll service provider you come across. Followthese helpful tipsto find the right payroll service for your business.